Severed Heads and Omens of Death: The Horror Origins of Halloween by Gary Davis

 

 

Preface

The article below is necessarily speculative.  The intent here is not to present a broad or recent history of Halloween, which has already been done by many writers; (see, for example, Trick or Treat: A History of Halloween (2012) and The Halloween Encyclopedia (2003, 2011), both by Lisa Morton).  Instead, the objective is to identify likely or plausible horrific elements of belief, culture and social behavior contributing to the origin and character of Halloween in the distant past.  This past almost certainly extends into prehistoric ages which produced no indigenous written records.  Thus, one is obliged to rely on uncertain inferences made from archaeological remains—buildings, earthworks, artifacts, skeletons, and preserved “bog bodies”—the latter exhibiting their own horrific features.  In some cases, written records from neighboring literate societies are available.  One can also glean information from stories, myths and legends handed down orally across countless generations; many of these were finally committed to writing during the Middle Ages.

The Halloween of today is conventionally encapsulated within the cheery, door-to-door exclamation of kids: “Trick-or-treat!”  Here we do not go in search of “fun-size” treats or other candy.  We dust off the ancient horrors lying behind the “trick”.

***

Probably no Western holiday has shapeshifted down through the years as much as Halloween.  The way it is commonly celebrated nowadays is quite different from celebrations just a few generations ago.  And there are greater differences the further one recedes back in time, to the Middle Ages, ancient history and the misty depths of prehistoric eras.  This mutability of Halloween celebrations is in fact a major reason for the holiday’s continued survival across many centuries; it is incredibly adaptable.

As the word “shapeshifting” implies, the outward form or practical content of Halloween activities has significantly changed over time.  There is a more consistent inner core of belief, myth and legend, however, that has been passed down from distant eras.  This core is derived from the ancient culture of the Celts living in Ireland, Scotland and elsewhere in the British Isles.  The Celts lived in intimate contact with dangerous and unpredictable forces of both man and nature.  There was necessarily a realm of “super-nature” that always hovered nearby, sensed if not seen.

The supernatural realm of the early Celts was one of threat, trickery and, by modern standards, outright horror.  It was especially permeable and open to contact with living humans during the transition from predominantly warm to predominantly cold weather marked by the Celtic new year celebration, called Samhain (“sow-in”) in ancient Ireland (began October 31-November 1).  This was a time when crops were being harvested, and cattle and other domestic animals were brought home from upland pastures; many of the animals were then slaughtered for winter provisions.

A successful harvest was an occasion for celebration at Samhain, including political/religious assemblies, feasting and bonfires.  Still, a specter of death lurked in the background at this time of year.  The temperature was colder.  Dead leaves fell from the trees.  The life-giving Sun remained below the horizon for longer and longer periods; people wondered if it would return.  The landscape took on a barren look.  In some years, there was a likelihood of famine if the harvest fell short; there was a threat of damage from fierce winter storms.  Warfare with hostile neighboring clans was always a possibility.

The noted Iron Age and Celtic scholar, Miranda Aldhouse-Green, has some strong words to say about Samhain:

The most sinister festival was Samhain at the end of October, a dangerous and liminal event that marked the end of the old year and the beginning of the new.  It was a period when time was in abeyance and the barriers between the spirits, the dead and living people were temporarily dissolved (Miranda Aldhouse-Green, Bog Bodies Uncovered: Solving Europe’s Ancient Mystery, 2015, p. 193).

Faced with so many uncertainties and dangers, the ancient Celts engaged with the supernatural realm in order to divine the future.  Omens of death, such as a raven spotted on the roof of one’s house, could appear at this time.  Fortune-telling games eventually became a staple feature of Halloween celebrations over the centuries; (see, for example, Ruth Edna Kelley, The Book of Hallowe’en, 1919; Robert Burns, “Hallowe’en” (poem), 1785).

The Celts populated their supernatural domain with a great many beings—deities, fairies and spirits of the dead.  Supposed fairy “sightings”, at any time of year, have occurred in Ireland and elsewhere in the British Isles into the 20th century.  They were particularly common, and often feared, in the 1600s and earlier, before the Age of Enlightenment.  Fairy battles tended to occur on Samhain.  (Richard Sugg, Fairies:  A Dangerous History, 2018).

Spirits of the dead included one’s ancestors and enemies killed in battle.  Celtic warriors often severed the heads of dead enemy warriors and kept the skulls as trophies in their houses (according to the ancient Greek geographer Posidonius (1st century BCE); numerous decapitated skulls have been dug up at riverine sites in the area of ancient Londinium, as well as headless skeletons in France).  Since the spirit or soul was believed to reside in the head, control of an enemy’s head could provide protection against his vengeful ghost, which might wander abroad when the restless underworld opened up on Samhain Eve. 

While not proven, there is a distinct possibility that the Halloween Jack-o’-Lantern evolved in tandem with the Celtic severed head trophy.  The candle inside the lantern represented the still living spirit of the deceased.  Early Irish Samhain lanterns were often made from turnips and rutabagas (pumkinnook.com).  Turnips seem to be shaped more like a human head than the later pumpkin lantern.  On Samhain Eve, the early Jack-o’-Lantern probably served a dual purpose: 1) to guide the spirits of one’s ancestors back to their family dwelling for a friendly visit and food treats, and 2) to ward or scare off the potentially dangerous and vengeful ghosts of one’s enemies.

Certain natural phenomena took on an extra dimension of forbidding supernatural meaning, especially at Samhain.  An example is the ghost or night lights called “will o’ the wisp” (also “fairy lights”, “fool’s fire”), caused by the natural combustion of decaying plant material and marsh gas in swamps.  These eerie lights could lure travelers to their doom, drowning them in deep swamp water. In Wales, people believed that the will o’ the wisp was “too bad to go into heaven and too clever to be taken into hell.”  This statement sounds a lot like the well-known legend of Stingy Jack and the first Jack-o’-Lantern. Again, there are horror origins to Halloween if one looks deeply back in time (Matt Soniak, “What’s the Origin of Jack-o’-Lanterns,” mentalfloss.com, 2012; Richard Sugg, Fairies:  A Dangerous History, 2018).

Were sacrifices performed on Samhain?  The answer is probably “yes”, given the need for divination and the propitiation of a dangerously open underworld at this time of year.  Animals brought down from pasture would have been readily available.  Was human sacrifice also practiced by the Celts on Samhain?  The answer to this question will likely never be known. The possibility cannot be ruled out entirely, based on the evidence of bog body “rituals”, severed heads, and the statements of Greek and Roman writers.  Julius Caesar, for example, made note of human sacrifices at Celtic festivals.  The writings of most Classical authors, however, were generally distorted by political and cultural prejudices; the Celts to them were nothing more than dangerous “barbarians”.

Regarding the bog body deaths, Miranda Aldhouse-Green states: “The weight of evidence for religious involvement strongly indicates that sacrificial rites were the main reason for the Iron Age European bog killings.”  Many of the bog body victims suffered a curious amount of overkill, even a three-fold death, that is inconsistent with a purely “legal” execution or death in battle.  The British Lindow Man, for example, was strangled, received a throat slice and two blows to the head.  Based on analysis of digestive remains, the bog body victims were generally killed in either wintertime or late summer to early autumn (pp. 175, 194), thus framing the period around Samhain and leaving open Samhain as at least a possible date for some of these killings (Miranda Aldhouse-Green, Bog Bodies Uncovered:  Solving Europe’s Ancient Mystery, 2015, pp. 191; 175, 194; Colm, “New Bog Body Found in Rossan, Co. Meath,” Irish Archaeology, irisharchaeology.ie, September 16, 2014).

Many people recall bobbing for apples in a tub of water during Halloween parties when they were kids.  Further back in time, apples were a major element in Halloween fortune-telling games.  The tub of water used in apple-bobbing, however, evokes a more sinister past.  Ancient Celtic legends include human sacrifices done by drowning in large cauldrons, which were significant ritual artifacts in their culture.  Such a sacrifice may be shown on the famous Gundestrup Cauldron.  These sacrifices were generally done in honor of the god Teutates (called Dispater by the Romans).  There are legends of Irish kings who died by drowning in a basin.  “…the sacrifice by asphyxiation in the cauldron appears to be attached to the feast of Samain (Samhain), the Celtic New Year…” (Jean Markale, The Celts:  Uncovering the Mythic and Historic Origins of Western Culture, Rochester, Vermont:  Inner Traditions International, 1993 (first published in Paris, France, 1976), pp. 231, 233).

How far back in time does Samhain go?  It probably dates at least to the final prehistoric era of Celtic Europe, the Iron Age of the 1st millennium BCE, prior to the partial Roman conquest of Britain in the 1st century AD.  (Most of the European bog bodies, including several found in Ireland, Old Croghan Man and Clonycavan Man—both mutilated in various ways—have been radiocarbon dated to the second half of the 1st millennium BCE.)  However, Celtic languages along the Atlantic seaboard—and perhaps the origins of Celtic culture—may go back much further, to the fifth millennium BCE.  Another hypothesis is that proto-Celtic culture dates to the Bell Beaker era of the Bronze Age, during the third to second millenniums BCE.

Archaeology magazine has reported interesting evidence of an advanced age for Celtic ritual culture in Ireland:

At the site of Tlachtga, on the Hill of Ward in County Meath—the site of circular earthworks associated with Samhain, the Celtic festival that gave birth to Halloween—recent remote sensing work has revealed three phases of construction, suggesting a long and varied ritual history that could go back more than 4,000 years (“World Roundup,” Archaeology, September/October, 2014, p. 20).

***

Whatever actual horrors thrived during ancient Celtic Samhain, the direct fear and terror they inspired are long gone.  Contemporary Halloween culture has preserved them as a distant collective memory, or half-memory.  “Trick-or-treat!”